The Story of a New Name

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐
Author: Elena Ferrante
Genres: Historical Fiction
Pub. Date: Sep. 2012
Format: Audiobook

This series infuriates me.

I hate all the characters and the plot is outrageous. But I can’t deny that this is *literature*. I want to scream at all the characters, but they are 100% a product of their circumstances. Our protagonist is the most frustrating because she is one of the few people to become educated and get the opportunity to leave the neighbourhood, but is ignorant to understanding what drives the people around her. Elena will only ever see herself as poor and because of her formative childhood experiences with Lila, does not recognize how how much better off she is than her friends. She is the only person with the real ability to leave the neighbourhood of her own volition, but fails to recognize her self-worth.

This theme is further reinforced through Nino’s character, who despite also being educated, is an idiot. In contrast to Elena, Nino is well aware of his self-worth, but is incredibly selfish and heavily influenced by his own ego. He takes no ownership over any of his actions and is happy to discard his relationships when they no longer benefit him.

What is the most difficult for me to grasp is Elena and Lila’s friendship. There is obviously a strong connection between these two women, but I’m not 100% sure what makes them friends. It’s clear they are drawn to one another, but it’s a relationship heavily influenced by competition. I want to believe that these are two dear friends, for whom jealousy eats away at their bond over time. But I’ve never seen any strong roots between these two characters. There was a brief period of simplicity between them as children, when they had the common ground of both being victims of their upbringing, but that bond didn’t seem strong enough to me to withstand all the trials they’ve put their friendship through.

For me, Lila is an inflammatory character. I know this is intentional, but the jealousy and competition between these two characters is so prevalent that it’s hard to believe the two could still tolerate to be around one another. After Ischia, there is an extended period of distance between them. For me it begs the question of when the meaningful and moving part of their friendship will be showcased?

But damn, this series is well written. I love a good unlikeable character and you cannot deny that Ferrante is a genius at distilling relationships. This does read like classic literature to me in that, it’s at times boring, it can feel extraneous and overwritten, and yet, even the most mundane of interactions serves to provide depth and nuance to a complicated cast of characters. The characterization is central to the themes of the novel, and yet the plot is still engaging and critical to the story. It’s a blend of these two essential elements of literature. It makes me want to beat my head against the wall at the ignorance and stupidity of the characters, but they are so well crafted that you can’t help to step back and reflect on what makes these people react the way them do.

I kind of hate it, but I can’t stop thinking about it. I definitely need a break from this series, but of course that ending has me wondering what more chaos and heartache Nino is going to bring to the story in the next volume. Most of all, I hope to see some real threads of friendship and selflessness between Elena and Lila. And I hope that Elena will finally start to recognize her own self-worth.

My Brilliant Friend

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Author: Heather Fawcett
Genres: Middle Grade, Fiction
Pub. Date: Jun. 2023

I finally finished it!

I’ve been working on this book for literal months. I’m shocked because it’s so beloved, but I found it incredibly slow moving and frankly boring. I was only able to finish it because I switched to a library audiobook for the last 100 pages. It did get a lot more compelling towards the end, but I’m not sure if it’s that the plot got more interesting or that it worked better as an audiobook. I listened to the sample months ago and thought I didn’t like the narrator at all, but actually, she did a pretty good job.

I do get why people like this book. I found it to be incredibly tedious, but I can still acknowledge that Ferrante is a perceptive author. I’m not ready to say she’s talented because of how slow the writing is, but her examination of relationships and conflict is very well done. I felt that she examined every facet of Lila and Elena’s friendship and every emotion that makes us human. Their relationship is very complicated, with both girls oscillating between admiration and jealousy. Elena’s infatuation with Lila results in an imbalance in their friendship and heavily influences the way she views herself. She wants to be like Lila, and her constant comparison between them only leads to her own unhappiness. Likewise, I believe that Lila knows she will never truly measure up to her brilliant friend and seeks to control Elena in other ways to maintain her own sense of self-worth.

At least, that was my interpretation of their friendship. But it’s so nuanced that I was never sure if these girls secretly loved or hated one another. I think there is a genuine friendship there, but it’s buried under many layers of conflicting feelings.

Ferrante goes incredibly in depth to the lives of Lila and Elena. While I found it quite boring for most of the book, I think it does contribute to the success of the story. Ferrante lives and breathes this world. It is incredibly well realized and nuanced, and I felt that I was living Elena’s life rather than just reading about it. This depth brings the characters to life, and I’ve always felt that a well realized set of minor characters is what makes a world so compelling.

I debated quitting this book around the 200-page mark and several people encouraged me to keep going. I wanted to finish, but I was pretty convinced I wouldn’t continue the series. I do admit to feeling the pull to continue now that I’ve finished. It reminds me of State of Wonder by Ann Patchett. The content couldn’t be more different, but it also took me months to finish State of Wonder, and when I did finish it, I couldn’t stop thinking about it. Even though I didn’t enjoy most of the reading experience, it made for a memorable book. I have a sneaking suspicion that may be the case with this book, so I’ll give it a few days and see if I want to keep going. I’ll definitely be continuing with audiobook if I do – I am a little intrigued.

Side note: what kind of author names their main character their actual name? This mystified me.